The Gulzar Chat
This is an unedited, verbatim transcript
mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 1:13 IST)
Koi Hain???
King (Sat Jul 17 1999 1:13 IST)
Hi everyone
mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 1:14 IST)
Shaam se Aankh main namee se hain
mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 1:14 IST)
Hi King
Suparn (Sat Jul 17 1999 1:17 IST)
Hi Mausam, gulzarsaab will be on at 5 pm.
Manish (Sat Jul 17 1999 1:50 IST)
Main Hoon
Niketan (Sat Jul 17 1999 1:58 IST)
Hi Is Mr Gulzar there
Niketan (Sat Jul 17 1999 1:59 IST)
What is the time in India
Deepak (Sat Jul 17 1999 2:16 IST)
Hello Mr. Gulzar
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 2:19 IST)
Umeed Hogi Koyi
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 2:22 IST)
Guys, are you there?
sudipto (Sat Jul 17 1999 2:46 IST)
hi
sudipto (Sat Jul 17 1999 2:47 IST)
hi
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 2:57 IST)
Hello, Gulzar saab. Kaise hai aap?
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 2:59 IST)
Hi guys. While we're waiting for Gulzar, why don't we chat amongst ouselves?
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:1 IST)
Hi , Gulzar Sahab kab tak ayenge ?
Amit (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:1 IST)
hi everyone... i guess darshan's idea seems great
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:4 IST)
Where should we start ? Should we start with his lyrics or movies ? Or should we start with his poems or any forthcoming gifts to us.
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:6 IST)
I think lyrics and movies first, then move onto poems?
AmitV (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:7 IST)
does anyone here have a record.. how many songs, lyrics, awards etc. of Gulzar sahib
Mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:7 IST)
Hello everybody
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:7 IST)
How about 'Mera Kuchh ..' ? Or 'Mora gora rang ..'?
AmitV (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:10 IST)
Yes, Uday those are lovely songs.. but i can't recall the films
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:12 IST)
Mera kuchh is from Ijaazat and 'Mora gora rang ' is his first song as lyricist and is from Bandini. By the way he has received 14 Filmfare awards and written songs for around 75 movies. With the avg. of 5 songs per movie it comes to around 350-370. Directed 17 movies out of which 16 are released and 1 (Libaas) unreleased.
AmitV (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:14 IST)
I think that speaks volume about his prolific ability
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:17 IST)
Absolutely!
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:18 IST)
No, its not the matter of ability. Its the matter of quality also. We have a singer who sings 28 songs a day does that reflect he superior to all the legends ? Certainly not. Its the beauty of Gulzar Sahab's work that represnts his capabilities. Think of 'Aaj kal Paon jamin par..' (Ghar) or think of 'Qatra Qatra milti hai ..'(Ijaazat) or 'Thoda hai thode ki jaroorat hai..' that speaks of his capacities.
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:19 IST)
Help me jog my memory here: is Bandini the film directed by Bimal Roy? And starring the late Nutan?
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:19 IST)
Countdown begins! 8 mins.
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:20 IST)
Yes Darshan you are right. Bandini is Bimalda's movie and starring Nutan.
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:21 IST)
Hi All
Mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:22 IST)
Hi mausam
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:22 IST)
Shaam se aankh main kuch nami si hain
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:22 IST)
Thodidi Zameen, Thoda Aasmaan Tinkon Ka Bas Ek Aashian ....
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:22 IST)
namaskaar ... Gulzar saheb aaye kya?
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:23 IST)
Thodidi Zameen, Thoda Aasmaan Tinkon Ka Bas Ek Aashian ....
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:23 IST)
Hey Uday , u know quite a lot.Can i ask u something??
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:23 IST)
hello sablog,
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:23 IST)
Hi Amit!
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:23 IST)
Yes, I will try to recollect from my memory.
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:24 IST)
Hi mausam: he'll be here in approx. 4 mins. But don't quote me on that, as I'm going on GMT!!
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:24 IST)
What does Marasim mean ???
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:24 IST)
marasim means relations. rishtey
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:24 IST)
Hi Vinay Kaise mizzaz hain aapke??
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:25 IST)
adaab gulzar saahab
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:25 IST)
The meaning of 'Marasim' is 'Relationship' and Gulzar saab himself helped us in understainding the meaning if you go through the inlay cards of CD or Cassette.
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:25 IST)
Adaab Arz, Gulzar sahib? Kaise hai aap?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:25 IST)
Thanx ,Vinay So here are we all But where's the man-in-Question??
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:26 IST)
Can anyone tell which movie is this song from, Thodisi Zameen, Thoda Aasmaan, Tinkon Ka Bas Ek Aashian.
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:26 IST)
Hey ajit , its from Sitara
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:26 IST)
WOW , Woh ghadi aa gayi . We are flattered ,Gulzar Saab
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:27 IST)
Good. Hello Gulzarji!
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:27 IST)
sir, dil se shuru kareN
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:27 IST)
Kya Gulzar saheb aa gaye hain
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:27 IST)
Namaskar Gulzar Saab.
sanjay (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:27 IST)
Mr. Gulzar i want to talk to u. if u recd this pls. revert me back.
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:27 IST)
Ummeed hogi koi... 5 baje warna koi aata nahi... ;-)
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:27 IST)
do u think Rahman did justice to you in Dil Se
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:27 IST)
Has Gulzar Sahab Come?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:28 IST)
Ek Shayar Tha ....That's my favourite . Kya likha hain aapne , Gulzaar Saab . Is it aapki Autobiography ,sort of
praveen (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:28 IST)
Gulzarji pranam.
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:28 IST)
Ek Shayar Tha ....That's my favourite . Kya likha hain aapne , Gulzaar Saab . Is it aapki Autobiography ,sort of
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:28 IST)
Can we begin Gulzar ji?
guniporgi (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:29 IST)
is anyone there?
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:29 IST)
Sir When is "Libaas" releasing?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:29 IST)
Sorry for spamming
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:29 IST)
Sir When is "Libaas" releasing?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:29 IST)
Libaas to release ho chuki hain ,yaar
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:29 IST)
gulzar saahab r u there?
Mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:29 IST)
Namaskar Sir, I want to request to you !!
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:30 IST)
Namaste Gulzar saheb
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:30 IST)
Has Gulzar Sahab Come Yet?
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:30 IST)
Hello Gulzar saab: kaise hai aap?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:30 IST)
Shukriya. Please answer my Qn:Ek Shayar Tha ....That's my favourite . Kya likha hain aapne , Gulzaar Saab . Is it aapki Autobiography ,sort of
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:31 IST)
Gulzar Sahab, Adaab. This is the postman from Karachi. Sultan-e-Mausiqui is at office he had also wished to join me now
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:31 IST)
Which company holds it's music rights now?
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:32 IST)
why is it not refreshing?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:32 IST)
Did Libaas have Vinod Khanna and Shabana Azmi in it or am i confising it with something else??
Nidhi (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:32 IST)
Gulzar ji, if u're online, will you please post a message?
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:32 IST)
Sir When is "Libaas" releasing?
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:32 IST)
Music rights of Libaas?
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:32 IST)
sir maine ek baar aapse poochha tha, ek sau solah chaaNd ki raatoN ke baare meiN (during one of your Jaipur visits). us waqt aap vyast the. please bataayeN, aap kin chaar mahinoN ka zikra kar rahe haiN.
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:33 IST)
Gulzar saab, given the subject matter of your recent films how difficult, if at all, was it to find a producer/distributer for them?
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:33 IST)
Sir When is "Libaas" releasing?
sandeep (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:33 IST)
hello gulzarsaab i am a fan of yours ..i am currently in singapore ..
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:33 IST)
Sir , if I recollect correctly I had read around 2 years back that there was a project in which you were working with Vijay Tendulkar for some movie. Is that project still there ?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:33 IST)
Complete this anyone ?? Woh Patte Patjhad ke Pedo se Utre they
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:33 IST)
Dil Se: kya aap sochte haiN ki jiya jale jaaN jale ke saath nyay hua (music composition-wise) ?
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:33 IST)
Sir When is "Libaas" releasing?
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:34 IST)
Sir When is "Libaas" releasing?
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:34 IST)
hello gulzar sb.. how are you...i am your new fan
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:34 IST)
Gulzar saheb, aapke andar ka shayar kya kehta hai jab aap 'kallu mama' ki bhasha mein baat karte hain. Kya language se kavita door ho rahi hai?
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:35 IST)
Sir When is "Libaas" releasing?
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:35 IST)
Mausam, pedo ki shakaon se..utre the! Phir utne mausam ghusre, woh patte do bechare, phir udne ki chahat nmain woh sehraon se gusre. Woh patte dil dil the. Woh rishte dil dil the!!!!!!! Etc, etc, etc
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:35 IST)
Hi Pagal ,what do u mean by New Fan??
sandeep (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:35 IST)
hello gulzaarsaab are u really there . aapko dil dhoondta hai ..
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:35 IST)
Gulzar saheb, Pancham ke baad Pancham ki said-reincarnation Jatin-Lalit ke saath kaam karne ka anubhav kaisa raha?
napethi (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:35 IST)
which is your favourite song (yours not included)????
Nidhi (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:36 IST)
fine, now it refreshes. I have always been fascinated by the way you use symbols in your poetry. shaayar chand se latak ke khudkushi kar leta hai.... have you written any more trivenis of late?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:36 IST)
Wah Darshan ,tune to dil ko choo liya
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:36 IST)
Sir When is "Libaas" releasing?
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:36 IST)
Gulzar Sahab Adaab, This is postman here from Karachi
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:36 IST)
sir, kya aapka sign. photo mil sakta hai..
sandeep (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:37 IST)
well gulzarji ..any words on Panchamda ...that come to your heart this moment ...
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:37 IST)
Maanga hain jo tumse woh Zyaada to nahi hain ,dene ko do jaan de du ,waada to nahi hain
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:38 IST)
sir, kya aapka sign. photo mil sakta hai..
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:38 IST)
milind , Gulzaar Saab has already answered ur Qn . See down
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:38 IST)
sir please answer me... when is "Libaas" releasing??
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:38 IST)
Gulzar saheb, Pancham ke baad Pancham ki said-reincarnation Jatin-Lalit ke saath kaam karne ka anubhav kaisa raha?
sandeep (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:38 IST)
long time back i sent some poems at your bombay address gulzaarji .. did u receive it ... sandeep
Nidhi (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:39 IST)
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:39 IST)
Question from Kashif (USA) i wanted to get your opinion about the future of urdu. and what should be the urdu -hindi relations since the are so close and yet different from each other.
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:39 IST)
Koyi tere wade pe jeeta hai kahan
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:39 IST)
sir kya mein bhi aap se baat kar sakta hoo.
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:39 IST)
Gulzar saab, tell me, although I am an NRI student in England, my hobby, if you like, is films, and more importantly, filmmaking. I am currently writing a script ( Hindi). Any advice or tips?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:39 IST)
Gulzaar Saab , Yeh ek so solah chaand ki ratein ka raaz ham bhi jaan chaahte hain???
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:39 IST)
Gulzar Sahab: Adab. Are you there and recieving my messages. Jehangir (Postman)
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:40 IST)
Sir When is "Libaas" releasing? Is "Libaas" an adaptation of Vijay Tendulkar's Play of the same name?
omesh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:40 IST)
sir,i've read ypur collection 'pukhraj'. could you tell me of your other works which have been published and where i could get them?
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:40 IST)
I know that sir. That's why I said 'said' - but I would like to know the experience.
Niketan R (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:41 IST)
Gulzar Saab I viewed your latest movie Hu Tu Tu recently. I felt it was very much a un Gulzar like movie. Why the change in directorial style, especially the end the blowing up of politicians. This is never in a Gulzar movie
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:41 IST)
Sir I have missed on the answer. Sir When is "Libaas" releasing? Is "Libaas" an adaptation of Vijay Tendulkar's Play of the same name?
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:41 IST)
Thankyou Gulzar ji for sharing your thoughts about RD. I miss him very much. Your songs give life to me!!!
sandeep (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:38 IST)
long time back i sent some poems at your bombay address gulzaarji .. did u receive it ... sandeep
Nidhi (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:39 IST)
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:39 IST)
Question from Kashif (USA) i wanted to get your opinion about the future of urdu. and what should be the urdu -hindi relations since the are so close and yet different from each other.
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:39 IST)
Koyi tere wade pe jeeta hai kahan
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:39 IST)
sir kya mein bhi aap se baat kar sakta hoo.
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:39 IST)
Gulzar saab, tell me, although I am an NRI student in England, my hobby, if you like, is films, and more importantly, filmmaking. I am currently writing a script ( Hindi). Any advice or tips?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:39 IST)
Gulzaar Saab , Yeh ek so solah chaand ki ratein ka raaz ham bhi jaan chaahte hain???
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:39 IST)
Gulzar Sahab: Adab. Are you there and recieving my messages. Jehangir (Postman)
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:40 IST)
Sir When is "Libaas" releasing? Is "Libaas" an adaptation of Vijay Tendulkar's Play of the same name?
omesh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:40 IST)
sir,i've read ypur collection 'pukhraj'. could you tell me of your other works which have been published and where i could get them?
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:40 IST)
I know that sir. That's why I said 'said' - but I would like to know the experience.
Niketan R (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:41 IST)
Gulzar Saab I viewed your latest movie Hu Tu Tu recently. I felt it was very much a un Gulzar like movie. Why the change in directorial style, especially the end the blowing up of politicians. This is never in a Gulzar movie
sandeep (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:38 IST)
long time back i sent some poems at your bombay address gulzaarji .. did u receive it ... sandeep
Nidhi (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:39 IST)
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:39 IST)
Question from Kashif (USA) i wanted to get your opinion about the future of urdu. and what should be the urdu -hindi relations since the are so close and yet different from each other.
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:39 IST)
Koyi tere wade pe jeeta hai kahan
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:39 IST)
sir kya mein bhi aap se baat kar sakta hoo.
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:39 IST)
Gulzar saab, tell me, although I am an NRI student in England, my hobby, if you like, is films, and more importantly, filmmaking. I am currently writing a script ( Hindi). Any advice or tips?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:39 IST)
Gulzaar Saab , Yeh ek so solah chaand ki ratein ka raaz ham bhi jaan chaahte hain???
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:39 IST)
Gulzar Sahab: Adab. Are you there and recieving my messages. Jehangir (Postman)
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:40 IST)
Sir When is "Libaas" releasing? Is "Libaas" an adaptation of Vijay Tendulkar's Play of the same name?
omesh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:40 IST)
sir,i've read ypur collection 'pukhraj'. could you tell me of your other works which have been published and where i could get them?
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:40 IST)
I know that sir. That's why I said 'said' - but I would like to know the experience.
Niketan R (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:41 IST)
Gulzar Saab I viewed your latest movie Hu Tu Tu recently. I felt it was very much a un Gulzar like movie. Why the change in directorial style, especially the end the blowing up of politicians. This is never in a Gulzar movie
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:41 IST)
Sir I have missed on the answer. Sir When is "Libaas" releasing? Is "Libaas" an adaptation of Vijay Tendulkar's Play of the same name?
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:41 IST)
Thankyou Gulzar ji for sharing your thoughts about RD. I miss him very much. Your songs give life to me!!!
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:41 IST)
Aaj agar bhar aayi hain Bunde baras jaayengi Kal kya pata inke liye aankhe taras jaayegi
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:41 IST)
Sir I have missed on the answer. Sir When is "Libaas" releasing? Is "Libaas" an adaptation of Vijay Tendulkar's Play of the same name?
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:42 IST)
Sultan-e-Mausiqui, Najma and Kiran are also sending there regards
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:43 IST)
maine abhi abhi aapke geet sune the..so i impress with you.
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:43 IST)
We have a singer with us here. Mausam!
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:43 IST)
sir, i think the one Gulzar that i like the most is the dialogue writer. Hu tu tu had some unparrellel witty ones. Why don't u write for films other than yours.?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:43 IST)
he sure did ,Sandeep . Kya acting ki thi unhone
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:43 IST)
Sir Whatever happened to your the movie "Hum Panchi Ek Daal Ke" whose script you were writing?
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:43 IST)
Gulzar saab, have your film scripts/screenplays been published? If so where and how can I get a hold of them?
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:43 IST)
Sir I have missed on the answer. Sir When is "Libaas" releasing? Is "Libaas" an adaptation of Vijay Tendulkar's Play of the same name?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:44 IST)
Are Ajit , main kya bataoo ,how deeply moved i am by his words??
sandeep (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:44 IST)
is it possible to communicate with you otherwise gulzarsaab, letter or email ..please reply
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:44 IST)
Why is it taking so much time to respond
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:44 IST)
Why is it taking so much time to respond
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:45 IST)
And songs Mausam! And with music like RDs, kya kehne!
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:45 IST)
Sir, What about 'Kabuliwala' ? I read that you were planning to work with Nasiruddin shah a film by 'Rashtriya Bal Yuva Chitra Santha' (Once Jaya Bachhan was its President). What about that movie?
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:45 IST)
Sir.. What are your future projects in script writing/lyrics and what will be your next directorial venture?
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:45 IST)
How the tranformation of soft romantic poet (Aajkal paaon jameen par) to aggresive and hard hitting (Phir kati gardan sir katne lage hai) takes place In last thirty years you were never so aggresive in film songs....
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:45 IST)
Gulzaar Saab : Please .Ek Shayar Tha ....That's my favourite . Kya likha hain aapne , Gulzaar Saab . Is it aapki Autobiography ,sort of
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:46 IST)
sir, i think the one Gulzar that i like the most is the dialogue writer. Hu tu tu had some unparrellel witty pieces. Why don't u write for films other than yours.?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:46 IST)
Jab bhi khayalo main tu aaye Mere Badan se khusboo aaye
sandeep (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:46 IST)
well gulzarsaab ab aur sabr baqi nahin.... kuch pal is turf bhi ..mod dein..to zindagi mile .. aapka ..shagird
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:47 IST)
Sir I have missed on the answer. Sir When is "Libaas" releasing? Is "Libaas" an adaptation of Vijay Tendulkar's Play of the same name?
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:47 IST)
maine abhi abhi aapke geet sune the..so i impress with you.
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:47 IST)
They didn't only leave you alone sir. We are alone too without them.
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:47 IST)
I think Vinay , same thing is equally true in Chupake Chupake or Masoom which are not directed by Gulzar Saab.
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:48 IST)
Gulzar saab, have any of your scripts/screenplays been published?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:48 IST)
Roz Roz Resham si hawa paas paas kehti hain sada
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:48 IST)
Sir.. Many of my muslim friends have felt offended by the use of the word "Khayanat" in the song "Chaiyya Chaiyya". Sir what does "Khayanat" mean?
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:49 IST)
Sir.. Many of my muslim friends have felt offended by the use of the word "Khayanat" in the song "Chaiyya Chaiyya". Sir what does "Khayanat" mean?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:49 IST)
Milind , Gulzaar Saab has already answered ur Qn .
nadeem (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:49 IST)
hello! i m ur great fan chating. i like ur poetry, ur written and directed movies ur short stories and ilike u as a lyricist too i want u to give me a little reply
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:49 IST)
Sir.. Many of my muslim friends have felt offended by the use of the word "Khayanat" in the song "Chaiyya Chaiyya". Sir what does "Khayanat" mean?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:50 IST)
it's not khayanat but Kaayanat And it means Heaven .Right ,Gulzaar SaaB???
sandeep (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:50 IST)
well sir, i have seen mausam more than 20 times ..each time i see it or listen to a song of mausam ..i live a life ..and i cry for sanjeev kumar ..may be he suffered in his life ..that he could enact that role in a "perfect" way ... and that song "dil dhoondta hai" the one with fast tempo ..(duet) ..i have lived it ..and still am living it ..
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:50 IST)
Aapke andar ka poet kya kehta hai jab aap 'Kallu Mama' type ka gaana likhte hain, jahan language crude ho jaati hai. Kya aapki usase ladaai nahi hoti?
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:50 IST)
Adaab, Do you have a record of all your self read recitals which are presently only found in between the songs of your albums
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:50 IST)
The songs, I mean the master tapes have not been preserved by HMV. Which we know since they are making CDs made from tapes recorded from LPs. Will your songs will ever be reproduced in their original quality?
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:50 IST)
Gulzar Sb. , Who is the most motivating person for you. Rakhee Ji or now your Daughter.
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:50 IST)
Sir please answer this question Sir.. Many of my muslim friends have felt offended by the use of the word "Khayanat" in the song "Chaiyya Chaiyya". Sir what does "Khayanat" mean?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:51 IST)
geeli meeti ki khusbhu Jhooth mooth ke shikve kuch ,,yaad dilado
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:51 IST)
Gulzaarji..hats off to you..i truly consider you one of india's greatest lyricists...tinkon ke nasheman tak...!..please enlighten me to the meaning of that line..
Milind Desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:51 IST)
Sir.. Many of my muslim friends have felt offended by the use of the word "Khayanat" in the song "Chaiyya Chaiyya". Sir what does "Khayanat" mean?
dizzy (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:52 IST)
with all the electronic revolution the awesome power of the internet and telivision .do u think that the indian film form ..i mean dancing and songs the pure fun and idiocy will give way to a newer form one that standardises itself to the world or do u think our type of films will become the poular form of the next millineum cansidering rajinikant is poular in japan
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:52 IST)
Milind, I think there was a case filed against Gulzar Saab in Auragabad Court for the same reason. I don't know what happened next ?
nadeem (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:52 IST)
i liked ur book of some afsanas named as "dastakhit"
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:52 IST)
sir ek sau solah chaaNd ki raateiN please?
Suresh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:53 IST)
Gulzar Saab, Namaskar from Singapore!
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:53 IST)
When is your new book expected?
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:53 IST)
anand. nasheman is nest - gharoNda
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:53 IST)
Ghalib ke alaawa aapke favourite Shaayar kaun-kaunse hain Sahir saheb ke baare mein aake kya khayal hain
sandeep (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:54 IST)
in mausam ...(even more than aandhi) each expression of sanjeev ji ..each smile or each sad scene ..was so full of intensity ..that ...its difficult to find "lafz" for them and the scene when he comes to know that sharmila had died ..(theres a glass of water in his hand) ...and the way he enacted ..does it remind u of any moment to tell us all ..
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:54 IST)
Adaab, Postman here. (Jehangir)
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:54 IST)
Woh Jo Shayar Tha ....That's my favourite . Kya likha hain aapne , Gulzaar Saab . Is it aapki Autobiography ,sort of
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:54 IST)
Hats off to you for Maachis! And other films too.
nadeem (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:54 IST)
which is ur most favourite and special personality in this global network
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:54 IST)
Sir, what has been your experience with Jatin Lalit in Khubsoorat?
Milind desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:54 IST)
Sir.. Many of my muslim friends have felt offended by the use of the word "Khayanat" in the song "Chaiyya Chaiyya". Sir what does "Khayanat" mean?
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:55 IST)
Ghalib ke alaawa aapke favourite Shaayar kaun-kaunse hain. Sahir saheb ke baare mein aake kya khayal hain
Gauri (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:55 IST)
Which of your films do you like the most>
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:55 IST)
Jaado ki narm dhoop aur aangan main baith kat
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:55 IST)
Jaado ki narm dhoop aur aangan main baith kar
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:55 IST)
Gulzaarji,
Milind desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:56 IST)
sir.. i did not get to see the answer . Sir can You please tell me when is "Libaas" going to release? And is it an adaptation of Vijay Tendulkar ji's play of the same name???
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:56 IST)
Saath Saath Tum Chalo to Raat Raat Bhar Chalein
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:57 IST)
Are you recieving all the messages because very slow response is coming as seen on the screen.
Milind desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:57 IST)
Sir.. Many of my muslim friends have felt offended by the use of the word "Khayanat" in the song "Chaiyya Chaiyya". Sir what does "Khayanat" mean? Someone here just said it means heaven. What is so objectionable about it?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:57 IST)
Pavan ,yeh kaunsa gaana hain???
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:57 IST)
Sir I am eagerly waiting for the film. Do you have any idea as to when it is releasing?
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:58 IST)
helllo mr. Gulzar
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:58 IST)
When is your new fil scheduled to be released
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:58 IST)
Sir,what do you think ? Where are we heading to ? Is there a hope of revival. The way now the politicians are playing with our lives? And the way the frustration is increasing is there a constructive way out of this ?
Stardust (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:58 IST)
aadab - Gulzar Sahab
Milind desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:59 IST)
sir.. i did not get to see the answer . Sir can You please tell me when is "Libaas" going to release? And is it an adaptation of Vijay Tendulkar ji's play of the same name???
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:59 IST)
Mausam : Its from Sitara. (One of the best albums with thodi si zameen and ye saaye hain)
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:59 IST)
Given the subject matter of many of your films, how hard was it , if at all, to find producer/distributor for the films. I ask you this because my script deals with a serious topic also. Please reply.
Niketan R (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:59 IST)
Is there a problem here, some comments seem blanked out.
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:59 IST)
Sir, Why Gulzar has became revolutionist who shouts against social and political corruption ?? You never made movies on these subjects before, ( Andhi was bit exceptional not fully), Why now ?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:59 IST)
gulzaarji, did personal life events(e.g. your divorce) make any changes to your poetry...did it make a better poet of you?..did your themes change?
Milind desai (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:59 IST)
Sir.. Many of my muslim friends have felt offended by the use of the word "Khayanat" in the song "Chaiyya Chaiyya". Sir what does "Khayanat" mean? Someone here just said it means "heaven". What is so objectionable about it?
Gauri (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:59 IST)
Hi this is gauri again. I wanted to know which one of your own films do you like the most?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 3:59 IST)
GULZAR SAAB : Kya aapne yah kabhi mahsoos kiya hain?? Jee main aata hain ,tere kadmo main sar jhuka kar ham ,rote rahe ,rote rahe . Teri hi aanko main aasoo ki nami to nahi
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:0 IST)
sir can i receive your sign. photo...pl..rpl..
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:0 IST)
Thanx Pavan Is it a film or an album???
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:1 IST)
Ref. Shailendra: thank you, sir. that's enough for me.. i don't want to know more
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:1 IST)
Adaab, Postman Here (Jehangir) Karachi
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:1 IST)
sir can i receive your sign. photo...pl..rpl..
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:1 IST)
Milind , Kaayanat means Heaven
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:1 IST)
gulzaarji, did personal life events(e.g. your divorce) make any changes to your poetry...did it make a better poet of you?..did your themes change?
sandeep (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:1 IST)
well gulzaarji ..yeh chand pal ..khoobsoorat to rahe ...phir bhi .. aapse..doori kuch kam hoti dikhayi nahi di .. khuda se yeh iltaja ..zaroor rahegi ..ki ek baar apse ..mulaqat ho .. khuda qayamat tak intezaar na karaye ..
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:2 IST)
gulzaarji, did personal life events(e.g. your divorce) make any changes to your poetry...did it make a better poet of you?..did your themes change
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:2 IST)
Do you know "Gulzar Deenvi"? (Did you wrote few songs with this name before 60s (Shreeman Satyawadi...)
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:2 IST)
sir can i receive your sign. photo...pl..rpl..
Suresh (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:2 IST)
How often does a lyricist influence the choice of a playback singer for a particular song? Can you, for example, ask the music director to use Kishoe Da instead of another singer? Have you done so?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:2 IST)
Sandeep , u r great ,buddy
anup (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:2 IST)
guzar g canI have your email address- anurag
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:3 IST)
sir ek Nit-Picking :) song: aapki aaNkhoN meiN kuchh antara starts with: lab hileN to... i guess it should be: jab hileN to what is correct, sir?
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:3 IST)
Sir,do you have an email account where I can get in touch with you?
sandeep (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:3 IST)
well gulzaarji ..yeh chand pal ..khoobsoorat to rahe ...phir bhi .. aapse..doori kuch kam hoti dikhayi nahi di .. khuda se yeh iltaja ..zaroor rahegi ..ki ek baar apse ..mulaqat ho .. khuda qayamat tak intezaar na karaye ..
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:3 IST)
Sir, Please tell me about ALL TIME GREAT SANJEEV KUMAR,Tell me about how he worked?? Specially for your films Mausam & Angoor , what homework he has done to grip the character ?? How he was getting those sharp reactions and expressions ??
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:4 IST)
sir ek Nit-Picking :) song: aapki aaNkhoN meiN kuchh antara starts with: lab hileN to... i guess it should be: jab hileN to what is correct, sir?
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:4 IST)
sir can i receive your sign. photo...pl..rpl..
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:4 IST)
vinay..it is labh hilen...when your lips move
Gauri (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:4 IST)
For the last time - which one of your own films is your personal favourite and why?
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:4 IST)
sir ek Nit-Picking :) song: aapki aaNkhoN meiN kuchh... The antara starts with: lab hileN to... I guess it should be: jab hileN to what is correct, sir?
Niketan R (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:4 IST)
Gulzar Saab Have you received my messages
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:4 IST)
Gulzaar Saab :Ek joke suniye Tum Aa Gaye Ho Noor Aa Gaya Hain Chalo teeno ghoom kar aate hain. Please don't mind . Just in a lighter vein
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:5 IST)
Are you recieving messages
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:5 IST)
Is 'Dil Padosi Hai' going to be ever released on CD?
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:5 IST)
Adding to Vinay's Q about a song How about Changing 'Mithi si mushkil hai na' in DIL SE should be 'Meetha sa jahar' or something.
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:5 IST)
gauri..i bet it is mausam
sandeep (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:5 IST)
well gulzaarji ..yeh chand pal ..khoobsoorat to rahe ...phir bhi .. aapse..doori kuch kam hoti dikhayi nahi di .. khuda se yeh iltaja ..zaroor rahegi ..ki ek baar apse ..mulaqat ho .. khuda qayamat tak intezaar na karaye ..
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:5 IST)
sir ek Nit-Picking :) The song: aapki aaNkhoN meiN kuchh... Kishore Da starts the antara with: lab hileN to... I guess it should be: jab hileN to... What is correct, sir?
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:5 IST)
Adding to Vinay's Q about a song 'Mithi si mushkil hai na' in DIL SE should be 'Meetha sa jahar' .
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:5 IST)
Sir aur ek bhasha se juDa sawal - is it right to keep the publicity matter and titles etc.. of Hindi films in English? and is it right for actors/actresses to speak in English in most off-screen appearances?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:5 IST)
All: Looks like time's over
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:5 IST)
Sir aur ek bhasha se juDa sawal - is it right to keep the publicity matter and titles etc.. of Hindi films in English? and is it right for actors/actresses to speak in English in most off-screen appearances?
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:5 IST)
sir can i receive your sign. photo...pl..rpl..
Gauri (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:5 IST)
Who is your favourite heroine?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:5 IST)
I was wrong
anup (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:6 IST)
namaste gulzar saab I am great fan of u how can I meet u -anurag purohit
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:6 IST)
sir ek Nit-Picking :) The song: aapki aaNkhoN meiN kuchh... Kishore Da starts the antara with: lab hileN to... I guess it should be: jab hileN to... What is correct, sir?
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:7 IST)
sir can i receive your sign. photo...pl..rpl..
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:7 IST)
Sir, do you think we dont encourage arts and culture as much in our education system as we used to? any suggestions on how this could change, if so?
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:7 IST)
Adding to Vinay's Q about a song 'Mithi si mushkil hai na' in DIL SE should be 'Meetha sa jahar'. Was jahar replaced by 'Mushkil' for the sake of tune?
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:7 IST)
Gulzar saab, aap kyon mere sawalon ka jawab nahin dete? Please dijiye ga nahin to mujhe mere ashkhon se sahare gham-e-zindagi jeena padhe ga.
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:7 IST)
Still waiting. Regards Jehangir (PostMan) Karachi
rpj (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:8 IST)
What after HU TU TU?ANY FUTURE PLANS.
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:8 IST)
sir ek Nit-Picking :) The song: aapki aaNkhoN meiN kuchh... Kishore Da starts the antara with: lab hileN to... I guess it should be: jab hileN to... What is correct, sir?
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:8 IST)
Sir aur ek bhasha se juDa sawal - is it right to keep the publicity matter and titles etc.. of Hindi films in English? and is it right for actors/actresses to speak in English in most off-screen appearances?
sandeep (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:8 IST)
aap theek kehte the .. woh aane waala pal jaa raha hai .. shayad chala gaya .. kuch lafz aur sunne baaqi hain .. intezaar hai .... keh dein to zindagi mile ...
Gauri (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:8 IST)
Aren't you going to answer any of my questions?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:8 IST)
Sir, do you think we dont encourage arts and culture as much in our education system as we used to? any suggestions on how this could change, if so?
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:8 IST)
sir mujhse bhi baat kijiye..pl
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:9 IST)
Pavan : We can't ask somebody why this and why not that . Meethi si mushkil main kya problem hain >>>
Suresh (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:9 IST)
My question regarding Amitabh Bachchan? Isn't he as great as Jack Nicholson.? Why don't you dirrect him in a role that'll do him justice? Otherwise we'll all miss out on his talents!
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:9 IST)
sir mujhse bhi baat kijiye..pl
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:9 IST)
sir ek Nit-Picking :) The song: aapki aaNkhoN meiN kuchh... Kishore Da starts the antara with: lab hileN to... I guess it should be: jab hileN to... What is correct, sir?
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:9 IST)
Sir, How easy or difficult it is to write 'Kabhi Kabhi yun mera Saaya jamin se uthkar ...' Or 'Aadate bhi badi ajib hoti hai..' and 'Uske ke paas bike hai' two different tones and moodes for same character of Maaya in Ijaazat.
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:10 IST)
gulzaarji, do you agree that behind every successful man there is a woman?..:-)
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:10 IST)
Till when will this chat session last I expect a response
om (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:10 IST)
gulzar saab, yr last 2 films were of a serious vein. any plans on making some light like angoor?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:10 IST)
gulzaarji, do you agree that behind every successful man there is a woman?..:-)
sandeep (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:10 IST)
aap theek kehte the .. woh aane waala pal jaa raha hai .. shayad chala gaya .. kuch lafz aur sunne baaqi hain .. intezaar hai .... keh dein to zindagi mile ...
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:10 IST)
Sir aur ek bhasha se juDa sawal - is it right to keep the publicity matter and titles etc.. of Hindi films in English? and is it right for actors/actresses to speak in English in most off-screen appearances?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:10 IST)
gulzaarji, do you agree that behind every successful man there is a woman?..:-)
anup (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:11 IST)
gulzar G ru there if you got my message please reply at- anewraar@hotmail.com
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:11 IST)
One li'l one :) The song: aapki aaNkhoN meiN kuchh... Kishore Da starts the antara with: lab hileN to... I guess it should be: jab hileN to... What is correct, sir?
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:11 IST)
sir aapka new album kab release ho raha hai,.
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:11 IST)
Gulzaar Saab: Aapki agli movie ka theme kyan hain??
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:11 IST)
Sir, I am young talented artist who is very eager to meet you. I have trying to meet since last six months. But each time I have been told that there is no new project so you can not meet. But Sir, I do not want to meet you for any kind of assignment or work, I understand it is not easy, it is very tough. Tougher than I think. I want to meet you because I need your guidance. Your movies, your stories, have influenced me much. That's the only reason I am requesting you to give some moments of your life
Suresh (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:12 IST)
Have you influenced the choice of singer/s for a particularr song? Like for example, would you tell a music director that Kishore Da would do more justice to a particular song? Any instances? Thanks!
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:12 IST)
sir aapka new album kab release ho raha hai,.
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:12 IST)
Will the viewers get to see another Angoor type film or upcoming films presently are all of different based scripts
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:13 IST)
One li'l one :) The song: aapki aaNkhoN meiN kuchh... Kishore Da starts the antara with: lab hileN to... I guess it should be: jab hileN to... What is correct, sir?
Gauri (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:13 IST)
Your daughter Meghna is now following in your footsteps. What do you have to say?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:13 IST)
gulzaarji, do you agree that behind every successful man there is a woman?..:-)
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:13 IST)
anand : gulzaarji, do you agree that behind every successful man there is a woman?..:-)
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:13 IST)
IPSY ::: Please clarify ur Question
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:13 IST)
Sir aur ek bhasha se juDa sawal - is it right to keep the publicity matter and titles etc.. of Hindi films in English? and is it right for actors/actresses to speak in English in most off-screen appearances?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:14 IST)
goodbye
ispy (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:14 IST)
"ipsy" nahee, it is : I-spy"
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:15 IST)
same to you sir... & thanks..
Gauri (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:15 IST)
Are u happy that Meghna is following in your footsteps?
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:15 IST)
Sir aur ek bhasha se juDa sawal - is it right to keep the publicity matter and titles etc.. of Hindi films in English? and is it right for actors/actresses to speak in English in most off-screen appearances?
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:15 IST)
Sir aur ek bhasha se juDa sawal - is it right to keep the publicity matter and titles etc.. of Hindi films in English? and is it right for actors/actresses to speak in English in most off-screen appearances?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:15 IST)
drive safely
sandeep (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:16 IST)
and how about jeetendra in khushboo and kinara ... wasn't the end of kinara .a bit too fast what do u say ..pleeeeeese reply
Vijay (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:16 IST)
Aap ki film "hu tu tu" box-office par flop kyon hui ? is it because of Sunil Shetty?
Niketan R (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:16 IST)
Bye Bye
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:16 IST)
same to you sir... & thanks..
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:16 IST)
Don't listen to the fake here!!
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:16 IST)
sir, u have given some more than obvious hints for your dislike of Mahatma Gandhi. The recent example being Hu Tu Tu (scene about Subhash ji's picture. Also O puri's monologues in Machis). Any particular reasons? Of course i don't agree (at least for once :))
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:16 IST)
Wishing you well for any future projects.
Suresh (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:16 IST)
Who was the best music director u worked with? Why?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:17 IST)
are yaaron let him go..paali hill tak ka safar bada lamba safar hai aaj kal ke mumabi ke traffic mein
anup (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:17 IST)
yes sir it require 2to make that also it's vey good idea don'tu have any script in your mind for that-anurag
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:17 IST)
GuLZAR SAAB PLEASE GIVE ME APPOINTMENT TIME PLEASE I AM TRYING SINCE SIX MONTHS
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:17 IST)
same to you sir... & thanks..
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:18 IST)
Suresh - it has got to be Pancham (I hope :-))
Suresh (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:18 IST)
Why don't you write a script for Amitabh and produces will surely come by!
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:19 IST)
oh..
Suresh (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:19 IST)
To Swastik: But he has done wondefully well with Madan Mohan and Jaidev too!
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:19 IST)
Sir aur ek bhasha se juDa sawal - is it right to keep the publicity matter and titles etc.. of Hindi films in English? and is it right for actors/actresses to speak in English in most off-screen appearances?
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:20 IST)
Suresh, very little, see the quantum of great work with Pancham!
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:20 IST)
Suresh: but me being a die-hard Pancham fan, will hope that way :-)
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:20 IST)
gulzaar ji..from which film did you realize that you and Panchamda had a special chemistry...
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:20 IST)
Sir, U have shifted from Khojyum I have been their many times
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:20 IST)
Gulzaar Saab : Kya aapne yeh kabhi mahsoos kiya hain ke aapke yeh words ne kitne logo ko chua hoga: Jee main Aata hain ,Tere kadmo main sar jhuka ke ham ,rote rahe ,rote rahe ,Teri hi aankho main aasuo ki nami to nahi
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:20 IST)
sir,, jaipur kab aayenge..
anup (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:20 IST)
bye for now hope to meet soon
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:21 IST)
sir,, jaipur kab aayenge..
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:21 IST)
Who is this 'GulZar' ? I am sure Gulzarji will never say that 'please buy my cassetes and CDs'. He knows that people love him.
gulzar (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:21 IST)
hello, goodbye and thank you for being with me!!! Jaatee hoo main!!!
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:21 IST)
You did lots of serials for children. 'Chaddi pehan ke phool khila hai', 'Guchha hai', 'Tap tap tobi' to 'Potli baba ki' which is not available on audio. Can you do something for bringing out these scores?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:21 IST)
gulzaar ji..from which film did you realize that you and Panchamda had a special chemistry...
ans (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:21 IST)
Are you getting into ad film making?
ans (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:21 IST)
Are you getting into ad film making?
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:21 IST)
Lagta hai ye GulZar ko apne raasta naapna chahiye
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:21 IST)
sir,, jaipur kab aayenge..
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:22 IST)
sir, u have given some more than obvious hints for your dislike of Mahatma Gandhi. The recent example being Hu Tu Tu (scene about Subhash Chandra Boseji's picture. Also Om Puri's monologues in Machis). Any particular reasons? Of course i don't agree with you
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:22 IST)
anand : gulzaar ji..from which film did you realize that you and Panchamda had a special chemistry...
sandeep (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:22 IST)
aap theek kehte the .. woh aane waala pal jaa raha hai .. shayad chala gaya .. kuch lafz aur sunne baaqi hain .. intezaar hai .... keh dein to zindagi mile ...
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:23 IST)
anand : anand : gulzaar ji..from which film did you realize that you and Panchamda had a special chemistry...
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:23 IST)
Gulzaar Saab : Kya aapne yeh kabhi mahsoos kiya hain ke aapke yeh words ne kitne logo ko chua hoga: Jee main Aata hain ,Tere kadmo main sar jhuka ke ham ,rote rahe ,rote rahe ,Teri hi aankho main aasuo ki nami to nahi
PAGAL (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:23 IST)
sir,, jaipur kab aayenge..
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:23 IST)
no Mausam, I guess he has better sense. He must have seen many more stupids. you see there's one thing that has no limits -stupidity.
anup (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:23 IST)
but note my email add & reply
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:24 IST)
Right Vinay and i think u r right
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:24 IST)
Right Vinay and i think u r right
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:24 IST)
Pavanjha, i am mehta from mumbai, u remember me?? is gulzarji left???
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:25 IST)
You did lots of serials for children. 'Chaddi pehan ke phool khila hai', 'Guchha hai', 'Tap tap tobi' to 'Potli baba ki' which is not available on audio. Can you do something for bringing out these scores?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:25 IST)
No Mehta .He is still here
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:25 IST)
gulzaarsaab, who amongst your contemporaries do you have the greatest respect and admiration for...is it saahir, Shailendra, Neeraj or somebody else..please answer sir...
Niketan R (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:25 IST)
Please throw out these fakes and let them not write stupid things during a serious chat and waste peoples time
Suresh (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:25 IST)
RD or SD?
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:26 IST)
Mehta : yes Vadan. He is still here.
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:26 IST)
Gulzar saab, aap mere sawalon ka jawab kyon nahin dete? Naaraz hain kya? Kam se kam hello to kahiye!
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:26 IST)
Ohhh thank god !! Gulzar Sir, What is relation between an director & an Actor as far as characterization of a movie character is concern? You dominate you actors OR your actors have free choice of act according to their perception of character & you just describe what kind of character you want?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:26 IST)
gulzaarsaab, who amongst your contemporaries do you have the greatest respect and admiration for...is it saahir, Shailendra, Neeraj or somebody else..please answer sir...
anup (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:26 IST)
GULZAR G PLEASE REPLY
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:26 IST)
POSTMAN STILL AWAITING REGARDS JEHANGIR & SULTAN-E-MAUSIQUI KARACHI
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:26 IST)
Thank you, sir. once again. aaj aap mere kai bojh door kar rahe haiN :)
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:27 IST)
Sir aur ek bhasha se juDa sawal - is it right to keep the publicity matter and titles etc.. of Hindi films in English? and is it right for actors/actresses to speak in English in most off-screen appearances?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:27 IST)
gulzaarsaab, who amongst your contemporaries do you have the greatest respect and admiration for...is it saahir, Shailendra, Neeraj or somebody else..please answer sir...
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:27 IST)
YOU SHOULD CONSIDER AMRISH PURI IN YOUR FILMS
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:28 IST)
gulzaarsaab, who amongst your contemporaries do you have the greatest respect and admiration for...is it saahir, Shailendra, Neeraj or somebody else..please answer sir...
Niketan R (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:28 IST)
There was a criticism that Maachis was one sided in its portrayalof the Punjab problem.It told the story from the terrorists point of view. What is your reaction to that
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:28 IST)
Gulzar Sir, What is relation between an director & an Actor as far as characterization of a movie character is concern? You dominate you actors OR your actors have free choice of act according to their perception of character & you just describe what kind of character you want?
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:28 IST)
I don't like the remixes either. Original is original!
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:28 IST)
gulzaarsaab, who amongst your contemporaries do you have the greatest respect and admiration for...is it saahir, Shailendra, Neeraj or somebody else..please answer sir...
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:28 IST)
ADAAB FROM JEHANGIR & SULTAN-E-MAUSIQUI WHERE & WHEN CAN WE GET UNRELEASED SONGS
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:29 IST)
gulzaar ji is it right for a great nation like Bharat to have a italianborn Prime minister?
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:29 IST)
Sir ek bhasha se juDa sawal - is it right to keep the publicity matter and titles etc.. of Hindi films in English? and is it right for actors/actresses to speak in English in most off-screen appearances?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:29 IST)
gulzaarsaab, who amongst your contemporaries do you have the greatest respect and admiration for...is it saahir, Shailendra, Neeraj or somebody else..please answer sir...
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:29 IST)
What an enrichening experience which we will remember for the rest of our lives
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:29 IST)
If I am not wrong you were a Khalsa College student?
anup (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:29 IST)
WHAT'S HAPPENING WHO IS THIS FAKE ENTERED HERE
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:30 IST)
Where did we all go wrong ? Is it education ? Is it religion ? Is it politics ? Or is it the mix of all ? The land which has given Gandhi, Subhash Chndra Bose and people like Bhagat Singh and Rajguru ? Every single person who laid there life for our country without thinking of there personal interest ? Now we see people who are ready to kill others for there personal paltry gains. We are seeing people using religion to destablise the society ? Who can take us out of this ?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:30 IST)
gulzaarsaab, who amongst your contemporaries do you have the greatest respect and admiration for...is it saahir, Shailendra, Neeraj or somebody else..please answer sir...
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:30 IST)
i
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:30 IST)
gulzaar ji is it right for a great nation like Bharat to have a italianborn Prime minister?
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:31 IST)
IF GULZAR SAHAB IS REALLY ONLINE IN LIVE CHAT HE SHOULD HAVE RESPONDED BECAUSE HE RECOGNIZES US JEHANGIR & SULTAN-E-MAUSIQUI
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:31 IST)
Gulzar sahab ek bhasha se juDa sawal - is it right to keep the publicity matter and titles etc.. of Hindi films in English? and is it right for actors/actresses to speak in English in most off-screen appearances?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:31 IST)
gulzaar ji is it right for a great nation like Bharat to have a italianborn Prime minister?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:31 IST)
Uday : Nobody can take us out of this . nobody is going to come and help u with it . We ourselves will have to do it .Each individual has to look within himself
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:31 IST)
Gulzaar Sir, What is relation between an director & an Actor as far as characterization of a movie character is concern? You dominate you actors OR your actors have free choice of act according to their perception of character & you just describe what kind of character you want?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:32 IST)
gulzaar ji is it right for a great nation like Bharat to have a italianborn Prime minister?
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:33 IST)
Gulzar sir, ek bhasha se juDa sawal - is it right to keep the publicity matter and titles etc.. of Hindi films in English? and is it right for actors/actresses to speak in English in most off-screen appearances?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:35 IST)
lol @ mausam
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:36 IST)
What projects are you working on now? What happened to Hum Panchhi Ek Daal Ke ? has that been Shelved after the exit of Shashi lal nair?
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:37 IST)
sir, i would like u to note two websites jo aapka palkeN bichhaye intezaar kar rahi haiN. 1) pavan's Gulzar page: http://www.rajcomp.com/pavan/gulzarpage.htm 2) My Pancham Site: http://pancham.cjb.net ...ham inetzaar kareNge tera qayamat tak..(maafi Saahir Saahab!) Please bina qayamat ke hi tashreef laayeN.
anup (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:37 IST)
HI ,EVERYBODY I THINK THIS IS OVER BUT TO CONTINUE IT WE SHOULD MAKE A GROUP/CLUB SO,REPLY ME AT MY EMAIL ADD-anewraag@hotmail.com
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:38 IST)
Gulzaarsaab...any regrets?
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:38 IST)
anup : we already have a club - master is PavanJha
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:38 IST)
ANUP: WHAT KIND OF CLUB YOU SUGGEST?
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:39 IST)
Gulzar Saheb, I have talked to Sky music (You worked for them in KARDI KATHA). They would be willing to publish the Children compilation.
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:39 IST)
Pawan :Wow,yaar . U r just great . Can i make a mirror site of ur WebPage with all the credits to u ,of course??
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:40 IST)
Hey Pavan: please check the link to the 'Nazm of the month'.
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:40 IST)
Gulzaarji befor you leave please give us a glimpse of your poetic genius and write us a couplet about LIFE..Zindagi
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:41 IST)
Yes Gulzar saheb, Please say something on the Net(the poetic aspect of the net)
singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:41 IST)
sir,what is your thinking about present indian song and old indian song
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:41 IST)
Welcome Ninad. U r just on time . IST time
singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:42 IST)
sir,what is your thinking about present indian song and old indian song
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:42 IST)
Mausam : Sure
anup (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:42 IST)
so what do u think
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:42 IST)
Gulzarji What is relation between an director & an Actor as far as characterization of a movie character is concern? You dominate you actors OR your actors have free choice of act according to their perception of character & you just describe what kind of character you want?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:42 IST)
gulzaar saab se hum sab ki taraf se dharkwaast hai ke weh abhi kuch shaahiri arz farmaiyen!
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:42 IST)
Ninad : Are You from Satya web site?
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:42 IST)
Sir, are you planning to work on similar projects like 'Marasim' or 'Dil Padosi hai' ?
Niketan R (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:43 IST)
GulzaarSaab joining in the request for a small couplet on the cyberage
singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:43 IST)
sir what is your future plan
Ninad (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:43 IST)
PavanJha: Hi . Remember me? we exchanged few emails when you visiteed the satya web site
anamika (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:43 IST)
Where can I see Gulzar ji's postings?
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:45 IST)
What is the URL for the Gulzar site? Anyone?!
rama (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:45 IST)
Gulzar saheb AAdab
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:45 IST)
Ajit: it is already on CD - I have it
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:45 IST)
Pawan :thanx a lot And i have registed for a page which is going to be very popular in the coming days . It's Gulzar.homepage.com . So If u want i can give u the passowrd and u can put up ur page there. Get back to me at patelsharad@yahoo.com
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:45 IST)
Ajit : HMV has released it on CD but it doesn't have all the poems of the original album.
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:45 IST)
Oh, thats great Amit. Thanks for the info!
anamika (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:46 IST)
I would like to hear ur explanation on the lyrics of "Jinke sar ho Ishq ki chaon"...
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:46 IST)
adab, jehangir (Postman)
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:46 IST)
gulzaarji..thank you for answering the question..Shailendra in my humble opinion too is certainly the gem of indian cinema....i esp. think his best Gem was the song Jaago Mohan Pyaare..the metaphorical beauty of that immortal song is just stupendous..
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:46 IST)
Did i miss something ??
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:47 IST)
lol@mausam...suna kijiya....lol
anamika (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:48 IST)
I would like to hear ur explanation on the lyrics of "Jinke sar ho Ishq ki chaon"...
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:48 IST)
gulzaarsaab any regrets....?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:48 IST)
gulzaarsaab any regrets....?
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:48 IST)
Gulzar ji, ek bhasha se juDa sawal - is it right to keep the publicity matter and titles etc.. of Hindi films in English? and is it right for actors/actresses to speak in English in most off-screen appearances?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:48 IST)
gulzaarji..any regrets?
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:48 IST)
Gulzar saab, any tips on screenwriting for me. I'm very very serious about it you know! In fact I'm more or less halfway through it already
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:49 IST)
Hey Pawan ,Ajit ,uday ,Vinay .Kya sahi main Gulzaar Saab ne kuch sunaya tha . Where was i ???Shit , i missed it
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:49 IST)
Anand : There are lot of Sahir songs which represent his capacities as poet. If we listen to 'Woh subah kabhi to aayegi..' we see the poet within him.
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:49 IST)
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:49 IST)
Gulzarji, What is definition of an Actor??
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:49 IST)
Gulzaar ji...please ek couplet...bas ..fir hum yahaan se ravvana...please gulzaar ji hum sab ki taraf se ..a couplet about LIFE
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:50 IST)
Mausam, ask Gulzar ji.
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:50 IST)
Gulzaar ji...please ek couplet...bas ..fir hum yahaan se ravvana...please gulzaar ji hum sab ki taraf se ..a couplet about LIFE
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:50 IST)
Gulzar Sir, Why Gulzar has became revolutionist who shouts against social and political corruption ?? You never made movies on these subjects before, ( Andhi was bit exceptional not fully), Why now ?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:50 IST)
Gulzaar ji...please ek couplet...bas ..fir hum yahaan se ravvana...please gulzaar ji hum sab ki taraf se ..a couplet about LIFE
Niketan R (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:50 IST)
Would you like to work with the new crop of actors (Aamir, Shahrukh etc). Who among them do you like. Or are the new crop of actors not upto the mark
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:50 IST)
Gulzaar ji...please ek couplet...bas ..fir hum yahaan se ravvana...please gulzaar ji hum sab ki taraf se ..a couplet about LIFE
anamika (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:51 IST)
I would like to hear ur explanation on the lyrics of "Jinke sar ho Ishq ki chaon"...
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:51 IST)
Amamika: As far as I understand, the phrase you mentioned means 'those who have the shadow of love over their heads.....will have heaven at their feet (paon ke niche jannat hogi)' Well, something like that anway!
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:51 IST)
What's happening??? Utter chaos
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:51 IST)
lol@mausam...hey mausam..rediff will have a transcript later of the entire interview..to be honest i dont recollect his reply..
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:51 IST)
Gulzar sir, pleeeease ek bhasha se juDa sawal - is it right to keep the publicity matter and titles etc.. of Hindi films in English? and is it right for actors/actresses to speak in English in most off-screen appearances?
Ninad (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:52 IST)
Gulzaar saab, continuing with my previous question, how was Chaiyaa Chaiyaa composed? You mentioned that it was originally a song by Bulley Shah, is the tune from the original song?
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:52 IST)
Sir, please itna sa kah deN ki aap ye site dekheNge. this is a plea from a huge Egroup of Pancham fanatics, which include Shaarang Dev ji too. the URL is: http://pancham.cjb.net
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:52 IST)
I repeat my Q? Gulzar Sir, Why Gulzar has became revolutionist who shouts against social and political corruption ?? You never made movies on these subjects before, ( Andhi was bit exceptional not fully), Why now ?
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:52 IST)
Gulzar ji, aapne 'Triveni' yeh form kaise sochha ? Aapnki jabaani is form ke baaren mai sunana chhahata hoo. Itni kripa ho jaayen to accha hai.
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:53 IST)
hey everybody..please write a line asking Gulzaar ji to write us a couplet..this session cant be complete without that..ok?..1..2..3..NOW..all of you please write down the request..
Ninad (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:53 IST)
Thanks for your reply Gulzaar saab, like all others in this roomm, I am a great fna of yours.
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:53 IST)
Uday ,what's TRiveni??
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:54 IST)
swastik, maiN tumse poori tarah sahmat hooN. aur gulzar saahab ki chuppi bhi maun sweekriti ka sanket deti hai.. :)
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:54 IST)
Shri Gulzar Sahib, If some young talented artist who has learnt many things from your movies, new to this mumbai, desperate to meet you & you only for guidance (not for any assignment or work), are you kind enough to give him some moments of your valuable time??
Ninad (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:54 IST)
Gulzaar saab, a friend of mine, Kajol, is trying to access the 'net to log on to the chat room. She called me that she is unable to do so and asked me to pass on her regards to you
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:54 IST)
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:54 IST)
great reply Gulzaarji
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:55 IST)
Mausam : That's what I am trying to understand from Gulzar ji. Its a poem with three lines only. That much I know.
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:55 IST)
yaani ye sahi hai ki angrezi hindi filmo.n me chhayi rahe? Gulzar saab kuchh to kahiye....
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:55 IST)
Pavan :Kya Hua ?? Kuch Bol
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:56 IST)
Gulzaar saab would life in India have been the same without Lata?
anamika (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:56 IST)
Kashif Hoda,is it?
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:56 IST)
Why is taking so much time that Gulzar Sahab's response is coming very slowly
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:56 IST)
Shri Gulzar Saheb, If some young talented artist who has learnt many things from your movies, new to this mumbai, desperate to meet you & you only for guidance (not for any assignment or work), are you kind enough to give him some moments of your valuable time??
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:56 IST)
Gulzaar saab would life in India have been the same without Lata?
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:57 IST)
waahhhhhhhhhhhh
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:57 IST)
Gulzar saheb, Many of my friends complain that your poems are too complex (Goodh). For a poet what is important a) his satisfaction or 2) mass appeal (in simple language)
kashif (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:57 IST)
gulzar sahib ! your serial on ghalib was much apperciated, will you be doing same thing for Meer?
swastik (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:57 IST)
waah Gulzar sahab waah
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:57 IST)
Gulzarji, What is definition of an Actor??
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:57 IST)
Never and also without Gulzar Saab ,Indian music wouldn't have had so much grace , mythical nature and Charm . Neither we would have got such HEART RENDERING COMPOSITIONS
Ninad (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:57 IST)
Gulzaar Saab, amongst all your films, which is the one closest to your heart?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:57 IST)
:-)......:-).....THANK YOU SO MUCH GULZAARJI......BAHUT SHUKRIYA ..BADI MEHERBAANI....
kashif (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:57 IST)
and you anamika?
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:58 IST)
Who would have been if Asha Bhosle was not there for all your major projects?
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:58 IST)
Gulzar saheb, Many of my friends complain that your poems are too complex (Goodh). For a poet what is important a) his satisfaction or 2) mass appeal (in simple language)
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:58 IST)
Remember when you vote, "Woh Jhootha hai, vote na usko dena ..."!
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:58 IST)
I am flattered to be here ,this evening . And i am going to remember this for all my life . ek shair ne itna sukoon kabhi pehle nahi diya . REDIFF ,THANX A TON .
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:59 IST)
I am flattered to be here ,this evening . And i am going to remember this for all my life . ek shair ne itna sukoon kabhi pehle nahi diya . REDIFF ,THANX A TON .
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:59 IST)
Gulzar ji, is it the same feeling that you are trying to convey through 'Bolo kya tum bas itnasa mera kaam karoge..' and 'Mera Kuchh saman..'. I haven't seen 'Daayara' but I have seen 'Ijaazat' around 15 times. But every single time I listen to both the songs I think that they resemble each other. Please comment.
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:59 IST)
kashif, gulzar saahab baithe haiN!
Ninad (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:59 IST)
Do you like making light movies like 'Angoor' or serious movies like Maachis? Which type do you prefer more?
kaju (Sat Jul 17 1999 4:59 IST)
hello gulzarji saalam
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:0 IST)
Uday ,which film is the first song from????
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:0 IST)
I AGREE WITH MAUSAM...THANX REDIFF FOR GIVING US THIS OPPURTUNITY TO BE ONEONONE WITH A LEGEND..
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:0 IST)
Hi Kaju Badam kahan hain??
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:1 IST)
Mausam : Daayra (Anand Milind)
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:1 IST)
Gulzaar saab would life in India have been the same without Lata?
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:1 IST)
Mausam its from 'Daayara' starring Sonali Kulkarni and Nirmal Pandey.
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:1 IST)
Thanx Pavan
anur (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:1 IST)
wah kya baat hai ,par aap ke under itna dard kyon hai
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:1 IST)
LOL@MAUSAM..U GOT A GREAT SENSEOFHUMOR BUDDY..
anamika (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:1 IST)
Kashif..i am posting this in my nickname.Remember my poem 'dastak' u put in ur page?And recently we talked about Pavan Jha's Gulzar page and "Jinke sar ho"?Thro mails,of course!
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:1 IST)
Anand: Never and also without Gulzar Saab ,Indian music wouldn't have had so much grace , mythical nature and Charm . Neither we would have got such HEART RENDERING COMPOSITIONS
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:1 IST)
Gulzarji, What is definition of an Actor??
kashif (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:2 IST)
gulzar sahib ! what direction is urdu poetry going these days? in your opinion , of course
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:2 IST)
Gulzarji, Why Gulzar has became revolutionist who shouts against social and political corruption ?? You never made movies on these subjects before, ( Andhi was bit exceptional not fully), Why now ?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:2 IST)
Anand ,where u calling from??
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:2 IST)
Pavan: both of us answered Mausam's question same time. I am waiting for Gulzarji's comment on that.
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:3 IST)
Mausam..agree..lets see if Gulzaarji responds..
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:3 IST)
Jane kahan gum hua Kahan khoya Ek aaso bacha ke rakha tha
AmitKS (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:3 IST)
Gulzar sir, ek bhasha se juDa sawal - is it right to keep the publicity matter and titles etc.. of Hindi films in English? and is it right for actors/actresses to speak in English in most off-screen appearances?
anamika (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:3 IST)
Gulzar ji..what next after MARASIM?Any plans to work as a joint venture?
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:4 IST)
once again, Adaab, Jehangir and Sultan Arshad Here!
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:4 IST)
US..email me sometime at anand-r@mailcity.com...would love to hear from a co-Gulzar fanatic!
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:4 IST)
Yesterday HUTUTU won one national award (Suhasini muley for best supporting actress). Congrats to you sir for getting her back to mainstream.
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:4 IST)
Sir, I am young talented artist who is very eager to meet you. I have trying to meet since last six months. But each time I have been told that there is no new project so you can not meet. But Sir, I do not want to meet you for any kind of assignment or work, I understand it is not easy, it is very tough. Tougher than I think. I want to meet you because I need your guidance. Your movies, your stories, have influenced me much. That's the only reason I am requesting you to give some moments of your life.
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:4 IST)
Ab 5 minute ki koi ahmiyat nahi hain . We already had a superb experience .
Ninad (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:4 IST)
Can we have more chat sessinos with you sir? maybe at a later date, whenver convenient to you. If you want, I can arrange it on my site
kaju (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:4 IST)
gulzarji kya mein aap se guftugu karne kee guzarish kar saktee hoon?
anupam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:4 IST)
Gulzarji....you there ? I am late...but you won;t find a fan like me....
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:5 IST)
JAAYIYE AAP KAHA JAAYENGE YE NAZAR LAUT KE FIR AAYEGI
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:5 IST)
Hey Anupam , u are right on time Where is Amrish???
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:6 IST)
Hey Pavan : can we get any info so that we can be in touch with Gulzar saab.
anamika (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:6 IST)
Eager to know... Gulzar ji..what next after MARASIM?Any plans to work as a joint venture?
anur (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:6 IST)
;swastik can i be a member of that club-anupagain logged as anur, email-anewraag@hotmail.com
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:6 IST)
ZINDAGI KE SFAR MEIN GUZAR JAATE HAIN JO MAKAAM......
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:6 IST)
Why is the flashback your favourite technique of film narration?
Niketan R (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:6 IST)
Would you like to work with the new star bunch (Aamir, Shahrukh etc) or do you feel that they are not upto mark
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:6 IST)
sir, though u din't promise, i know u would be there. http://pancham.cjb.net. please make your presense felt, sign the guest book...
Ninad (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:7 IST)
Can we have more chat sessions with you sir? maybe at a later date, whenver convenient to you. We all would love to have more of such sessions
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:7 IST)
Pavan ,Uday ,Anand :Do we have a Gulzar-specific mailing list ???
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:7 IST)
Gulzarji, Dil Dhoonta hai phir wohi fursat ke raat din. Baithe rahe apase baaten kiye huye. (Apaki maafi chhahata hoo. For playing with the words.)
AmitKS (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:8 IST)
Gulzar sir, ek bhasha se juDa sawal - is it right to keep the publicity matter and titles etc.. of Hindi films in English? and is it right for actors/actresses to speak in English in most off-screen appearances?
anupam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:8 IST)
Gulzarji.....can you give your fans your own e-mail add ....please......
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:8 IST)
Amit, while you were away, he replied: Gulzar : Swastik: Straightaway to confess. NO. In foriegn film festivals many a times we have been questioned that why Indian and Pakistani films have English titles and the language of the film was not the same. In our own country it's not the same with Bengali and South India films, whether Tamil, Telegu, Kanada, Malayam... It's only in Hindi and Urdu films that we have this. I think it's more for the trade reasons that it has been imposed on us. Secondly English provides the all India link. For the second part of your question, it's not fair to speak English in Hindi programs and keep punching Hindi into English programs. Kyon theekh hai ki nahin?:-)
kaju (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:8 IST)
gulzarji mein bhi isi art feild se talluk rakhtee hoon aur aap kee fan hoon, aap bahut achha likhtey hai yeh koi kehne kee baat to nahin hai sabhi jantey hai...lekin u r really out of the world...u r fabulous
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:8 IST)
BAS EK CHUP SI LAGI HAI. NAHIN UDAAS NAHIN.
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:9 IST)
gulzaarji....hum sab ki taraf se...BAHUT BAHUT DHANYAWAAD..AAP AAYE..CHAND BAATEIN KI....WE ARE VERY GRATEFUL AND ENRICHED....AISE MAUKE BAHUT KAM NASSEB HOTE HAIN...ONCE AGAIN THANK YOU.....KHUDA AAPKO LAMBI UMAR DE..SO THAT WE MAY ALL BENEFIT FROM YOUR INSPIRATIONAL PEN
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:9 IST)
Gulzar Saab : Tum jo keh do to Aaaj ki raat chaand doobega nahi ,Raat ko rok lo , Raat baat hain aur Zindagi Baaki to nahi
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:9 IST)
AmitKs : Please don't spam. the Question is answered by Non other than GulzarJi
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:9 IST)
Mausam: is there a Gulzar specific mailing list? if so can I be on it?
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:9 IST)
Abhi na parda giraao Thehro
AmitKS (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:9 IST)
shukriya Vinay bhai :-)
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:10 IST)
Gulzarji.. I want to meet you, Please sir,, I have been at Khojium Apt. many times, Please sir,
kashif (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:10 IST)
where would you rank yourself in urdu poetry? in which group ? and what do you think you contributed to urdu poetry. ?
Jehangir (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:10 IST)
are you there>? Sultan Arshad & Jehangir here Karachi
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:10 IST)
Yes gulzarfans@rajasthan.net More than 150 members Please write to me if you want to be a part of that at gulzarfan@rajasthan.net or pavanjha@yahoo.com
AmitKS (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:10 IST)
Uday I was disconnected and missed the reply. sorry to all fellow fans :-)
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:11 IST)
Pavan : I posted a mail on gulzarfans@rajsthan.net but I did not receve the mail. Did you receive it.
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:11 IST)
THANKS PAVAN
anur (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:11 IST)
same to u mehta/anand/jehangir
kaju (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:11 IST)
sir which is ur next film after hu tu tu...i saw th movie it is great...
anamika (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:11 IST)
Eager to know... Gulzar ji..what next after MARASIM?Any plans to work as a joint venture?
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:11 IST)
sir, i recall once some programme held titled - Ghalib se Gulzar tak.. and you participated in that too. how much do u identify yourself with Mirza sahib?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:11 IST)
Pavan ,U R Just Great . where are u now??? Jaipur ??
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:12 IST)
sir, i recall once some programme held titled - Ghalib se Gulzar tak.. and you participated in that too. how much do u identify yourself with Mirza sahib?
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:12 IST)
Sir, what about 'Triveni' ?
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:13 IST)
Uday : gulzarfans@rajasthan.net is restricted. You can send it to gulzarfan@rajasthan.net (both the id's are different)
AmitKS (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:13 IST)
Sir when will Khubsoorat's audio be released? Any clues?
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:13 IST)
Hey Pavan, Vinay, Mausam we all can continue talking of course afterwards.
anamika (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:13 IST)
Eager to know... Gulzar ji..what next after MARASIM?Any plans to work as a joint venture?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:13 IST)
GULZAARJI ..EK AAKHRI SAWAAL..INDIA'S GREATEST SON/DAUGHTER..YOUR VOTE?
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:13 IST)
sure Uday...
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:13 IST)
sir, i recall once some programme held titled - Ghalib se Gulzar tak.. and you participated in that too. how much do u identify yourself with Mirza sahib?
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:14 IST)
Aaj Bichhade Hain Kal Ka Dar Bhi Nahi
AmitKS (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:14 IST)
shukriya Gulzar ji... khuda hafiz
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:14 IST)
vida
Ajit Singh (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:15 IST)
Thank you very much Gulzar ji!
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:15 IST)
ALVIDA..SHUKRIYA..
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:15 IST)
Aaj Bichhade Hain Kal Ka Dar Bhi Nahi , Alvida
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:15 IST)
so uday, where r u from?
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:15 IST)
Thanks Gulzar ji. Yeh Ek zindagi bhar ke liye ehasas rahenga ki humane aapse baten ki.
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:15 IST)
Gulazar sahib, see you soon
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:15 IST)
Gulzar Fan Club ki Or se Dhanyawaad - Pavan http://www.rajcomp.com/pavan/gulzar.htm
anamika (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:15 IST)
Tata
Ninad (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:16 IST)
(From Harsh Chhaya) gulzar sahab, you may not remember but i had met you through Mr. Salim Arif about a month back,main ab-bhi dua kar raha hun ki mujhe ya aapko producer mile jisse hum dono ka kaam ho jaaye, of course i am an actor!
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:16 IST)
Thanks to Gulzar for chatting to us, and to rediff.com for providing a platform upon which we can chat to Gulzar saab.
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:16 IST)
thanks to rediff people. Suparn, Sharmila, Nikhil Thanks a lot
anur (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:16 IST)
note my email too-anurapurohit@yahoo.com
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:16 IST)
WHEW WE DID IT THANX REDIFF
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:16 IST)
Vinay : I am from Malegaon in Nasik District Maharashtra. I am right now in Detroit, US.
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:17 IST)
Ninad : are you the webmaster of Satya?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:17 IST)
3 CHEERS FOR REDIFF
shaarangdev (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:17 IST)
Aa daab, Gulzar saheb, this is Shaarang here
Ninad (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:17 IST)
yes Pavan
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:17 IST)
Pavanji, has Gulzar saab gone??
kaju (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:17 IST)
it was in my knowledge that you r in someway or the other influenced by osho's philosophy & pls reply don't ignore ur fans like this
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:17 IST)
Welcome ,ShaarangJee
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:17 IST)
SHAARANG..WELCOME....RIGHT ON TIME..
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:17 IST)
what else than Gulzar?
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:18 IST)
Shaarang ji u r a little late
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:18 IST)
we can have a shaarang dev chat session now?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:18 IST)
BYE MAUSAM
kashif (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:18 IST)
zindagi ghazal kyuN nahi lagti???
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:19 IST)
Kaju , Gulzaar Saab has left . Bad Luck And sorry for my rudeness earlier. Hope u take it in the right spirit . I had to say something funny beacuse the environment was getting a bit heavy with Pavan getting a bit senti
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:19 IST)
Yes
Ninad (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:19 IST)
Nice suggestion Pavan. I'm sure everyone would love it.
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:20 IST)
bye pavan/ninad
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:20 IST)
Kashif: Woh bhi dukh bhari
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:20 IST)
Gulzarsaab has left. Mera ek khawb toot gaya,, chalon dusara banayen
Ninad (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:20 IST)
bye anand
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:20 IST)
Pavan : cool website you have!!
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:20 IST)
kashif, ghazal udas nahiN hoti kya?
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:20 IST)
Sharang ji, it was nice experience to hear 'Labone se choom lo haathose tham lo mujhako..'. What do you think about the experience of the compostion?
anand (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:21 IST)
mausam..u got email ad?
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:21 IST)
Kashif : Kyonki tum soye rahte ho.
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:21 IST)
Darshan : Thanks
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:21 IST)
Take Care All of u Had a nice time And Pavan , if u come to Bangalore , it would be my peasure to meet a person like u . Mail me at patelsharad@yahoo.com
guru (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:21 IST)
Jai hind people... Has our poet come in yet?
kashif (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:22 IST)
i think zindagi will be closer to ghazal since all the shers of ghazal even though being of same bahar and radeef may have different topics, like life... not nazm which has one story.
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:22 IST)
Guru : you a little late. He just left.
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:22 IST)
Gulzarsaab has left. Mera ek khawb toot gaya,, chalon dusara banayen
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:23 IST)
Anand ,it's patelsharad@yahoo.com
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:23 IST)
Do visit Gulzar : The Garden of Songs (http://www.rajcomp.com/pavan/gulzar.htm). If you want to be a part of Gulzar Fan club (150 members) please write to me at gulzarfan@rajasthan.net
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:23 IST)
tumhari zindagi to miyaaN nazm jaisi hi l;agti hai. har baar ghoom phir ke waheeN pahuNch jaate ho :)
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:23 IST)
Guru: JAI HIND. Woh aaye bhi aur chand baatein kar ke chale bhi gaye.
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:23 IST)
Pavan and Vinay are you still there ?
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:23 IST)
uday ,Guru is not a bit late .He's too late
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:23 IST)
Vadan : Ek hi khwab kai baar dekha hai meine
Ninad (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:23 IST)
Pavan: Thanks for the URL. I had lost it after my ol' machine crashed
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:24 IST)
yes Uday, very much, both of us. from the same place on the earth
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:25 IST)
Bye Vinay ,Uday and Pavan
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:25 IST)
Pavan ji, Khawab to Khawab hote hein, Haqikat hain. Khawabon ko Haqikat karte karte mein khud ek khawb ban kar rahe gaya hun
Mausam (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:25 IST)
Had a nice time with u all
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:25 IST)
I know that you are from same place so I asked the question to both of you. Where should we start ?
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:25 IST)
bye mausam. hope to see you again
Ninad (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:25 IST)
Mausam: Same here !
kashif (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:25 IST)
ji vinay sahib, lekin hamesha unwaan badal jaata hai LOL
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:25 IST)
Bye Mausam
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:27 IST)
OK Mausam Anamika Ninad Pavan Vinay Uday Mehta Kashif aur baaki sab Gulzar ke chahne wale...Main ijaazat chahunga....Agli baar shaiyad fan club main mulaquaat hogi!
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:27 IST)
Vadan : Roz roz aankho tale, ek hi sapna pale Raat bhar kajal jale, aankh mein jis tarah khwaab ka diya jale
Ninad (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:27 IST)
Folks, gotta go. It was a really nice experience talking with Gulzaar Saab and you all. Pavan: I'll send you a mail later. Ok? It was nice talking to you after a long time
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:27 IST)
Buy, darshanji
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:27 IST)
zaroor, darshan
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:27 IST)
Darshan : Goodbye, see you soon
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:27 IST)
Pavan , Vinay aapka aaj ke chat ke baare mai kya khayal hai ? Aap abhi Jaipur mai ho ya Gulzar Saab ke saath B'bay mai ho.
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:28 IST)
bye Ninad, see you
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:28 IST)
uday: jaipur meiN hi haiN. itne naseebwaale bhi naheeN..:)
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:29 IST)
Uday : Vinay is sitting with me right now
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:29 IST)
mere liye to lifetime experience tha. waise maiN unse personally bhi mil chuka hooN aur uski to baat hi kuchh aur thi
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:31 IST)
Are doston Is garib ki bhi suno.. mein mumbai mein hi rahata hun. Since lastSix mohths i am trying to meet mr.gulzar and failing . today i had a big hope but it crashed tooo
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:31 IST)
Yaar, unse milane ko bahot dil karata hai. Ek baar Poona mai the tab mai kahi bahar gaya tha aur jab wapas poona pohachha to programme khatm ho chooka tha. Aaj ka experience really lifetime experience raha.
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:31 IST)
how could u have meet him today. but it was almost meet-like
kashif (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:31 IST)
zindagi ghazal ki tarah hai adh-khile kamal ki tarah hai abhi abhi naazil hua hai. :-)
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:32 IST)
uday: mail id?
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:32 IST)
miyaaN, gulzaar ke baad youN bemaza na karo.. :)
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:33 IST)
vinay : mail id hai udayrajd@hotmail.com. Pavan ka mail id to hai. Aapka nahi hai.
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:33 IST)
Has anyone goy Gulzarsaab's mailid
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:33 IST)
mine is vpj@bigfoot.com meri site dekhna. pancham.cjb.net
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:34 IST)
Woh site to dekh chuka hoo. Bahot acchi site hai. Par us site ka frequent flyer nahi hoo. Aaj hi use book mark kar doonga.
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:34 IST)
Hello,everyone,has Mr.Gulzar left?
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:35 IST)
if u happen to be a rd fan. you can also join the pancham egroup.
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:35 IST)
Gulzarsaab has left. Mera ek khawb toot gaya,, chalon dusara banayen
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:35 IST)
Shruti : yes he was here for about a hour and it was a nice experience.
kashif (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:35 IST)
and my e-mail if any one cares is kashif@urdustan.com :-) gulzar sahib! please note. ;-)
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:35 IST)
Visit Gulzar site : GULZAR - The Garden of Songs (http://www.rajcomp.com/pavan/gulzar.htm)
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:35 IST)
Vinay : Surely.
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:35 IST)
Has anyone goy Gulzarsaab's mail id ???
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:36 IST)
Has anyone got Gulzarsaab's mailid
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:36 IST)
Vadan : you can get it from me
Darshan (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:37 IST)
Pavan: if you are still there could you give out the email to the fan club once again. Thanks
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:37 IST)
Hey pavan I will send you a mail. Please let me know HIS email id.
mehta (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:37 IST)
Thank you Pavanji AAP TO JANTE HEIN, DUBTE KO TINAKE KA SAHARA HI BAHOT....
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:38 IST)
Darshan : Just write to me at gulzarfan@rajasthan.net
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:39 IST)
What time is the chat?
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:40 IST)
Did you get to speak a lot to him,Uday?
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:40 IST)
Ok Guys, It was a great experience Phir milte hai Saare ke saare gaamaa ko lekar gaate chale...
MEHTA (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:41 IST)
Pavanzi, shukriyaaa Dhanyawaad
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:41 IST)
Keep in touch through email. udayrajd@hotmail.com
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:42 IST)
shruti : You can check the transcript in few days
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:42 IST)
Could someone teach me how to have a conversation here?! I'm a bit of a novice-Uday,You didn't answer my question
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:43 IST)
Shruti : I was not able to speak to him. But yes we got to know some of his views. He answered two of questions. One directly and another indirectly.
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:43 IST)
So,are all of you major Gulzar fans?
MEHTA (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:43 IST)
Yes Shruti
MEHTA (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:44 IST)
Where r you shruti.\?? i am from mumbai
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:44 IST)
Shruti : it takes some time to answer and I answered your questin.
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:44 IST)
Which one's?
vikram (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:45 IST)
hi room
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:45 IST)
what were the questions you asked,Uday?
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:45 IST)
Shruti : I'll try to post chat transcript on my site. Anyway it would be available on Rediff in few days. My Gulzar site address is http://www.rajcomp.com/pavan/gulzar.htm
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:46 IST)
Shruti : Pavan has done a great work of creating a home page for Gulzar Saab. You can visit that site at. Www.rajcomp.com/pavan/gulzar.htm. We are Gulzar's fan. And I don't like ranking the likings.
pavanjha (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:47 IST)
Tum gaye sab gaya Mein apni hi mitti tale dab gay Bye everybody
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:47 IST)
Shruti:I did not ask any question. I said I answered your question.
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:47 IST)
See you Pavan.
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:48 IST)
Its fantastic that someone's created a website on him,long overdue,I might add.Good work,Pavan.Does it have Mr.Gulzar's sanction though?
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:48 IST)
So,what did he say?
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:48 IST)
So,what did he say?
Ashish (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:49 IST)
Is Gulzar sahab around or has he left ??
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:49 IST)
Shruti: If you are talking about the questions to Gulzar Saab then I asked him 'Does he have the effect of Partition still on his mind ?' and other one was 'What is the future of the country ?' The way he perceives it.
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:50 IST)
Hey ashish. Are you ashish bokil ? Are you still in Texas ?
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:50 IST)
This is an awfully slow place,I can't seem to find anyone else's reply if someone's answering me,that is
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:50 IST)
can't be ashish bokil?
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:51 IST)
anyone there?
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:51 IST)
Vinay : why he can't be ashish bokil ?
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:51 IST)
And what did he say?I know partition is still very much on his mind;it's there in his songs
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:51 IST)
I am still here and ready to talk to everybody interested to continue the talk.
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:53 IST)
Shruti : He said that its on his mind and he tried to get out of it. But he won't be able to get rid of it till the same violence and riots are taking place around all of us.
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:53 IST)
I'd like to talk to you about Mr.gulzar,if the server here permits me!
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:53 IST)
beacuse i have contacted him so many times without any avail
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:53 IST)
I don't have any problems.
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:54 IST)
so do i
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:54 IST)
Hey vinay : I think the postings by ashish are very old and if he was student then then he must be out of that univ. by this time.
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:55 IST)
he's written some of the most amazingly sensitive punjabi/urdu poetry I've read in a while
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:55 IST)
Uday: u never seem to be on RMIM
kashif (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:55 IST)
pavan sahib, what did gulzar sahib said that he is making a web site for himslef? what's the address?
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:55 IST)
Uday,would you know how to contact him in Bombay?
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:56 IST)
Should we talk about his movies as director or should talk about his songs and dialogues?
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:56 IST)
no, it was not Gulzar sahab i guess, someone else. it is gulzar.homepage.com
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:56 IST)
as i said earlier i like the dialogue parts. though no doubt he weaves magic with his poetry too
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:57 IST)
I only know that he lives in West Bandra. That's it. I am looking for a chance to meet him desperately.
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:58 IST)
I've found both fascinating-but his songs and poetry are more interesting-so lets talk about those
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:58 IST)
he is not as good a director. may be good storyteller. Overall he is a quite suljha hua person. and his wit and intellect place him in Ghalib's league, though his work is not as extensive as Ghalib's
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:58 IST)
I've found both fascinating-but his songs and poetry are more interesting-so lets talk about those
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 5:59 IST)
Where should we start ? Should start with Masoom, Aandhi, Ijaazat, Mere Apne, Anand or sheer comedy of Chupake Chupake and Angoor. i am ready for everything.
kashif (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:0 IST)
vinay i don't think he is anywhere near ghalib. no one has ever able to come near ghalib. and gulzar is no exception. is it news to gulzar fans???
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:0 IST)
masoom's one of my favourites
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:0 IST)
Me too,to want to him desperately would be an understatement.I think there must be loads of people like us,wanting to meet him!People fine his 'star ' qualitie attractive,I guess.I love his intensity and simplicity and his passion about punjab and '84
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:0 IST)
Now its a problem Vinay/Shruti. I toss between both of you and decide. I agree to Vinay's view that he is not a great director as he is great writer or poet.
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:1 IST)
no kashif. i just said he is in the same league of shaayrs, who used wit in their poetry
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:1 IST)
massom was by Shekhar kapoor.Gulzar made Mausam with sanjeev kr.and sharmila tagore.
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:2 IST)
masoom's dialogues and story was Gulzar's. that's what i like about the movie most, of course songs apart.
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:3 IST)
Masoom was by Shekar Kappor but dialogues and lyrics are by Gulzar.
kashif (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:3 IST)
ok bhaaiyoN aur bahnoN! kaam pe jaana hai, unlike some of you i don't have sarkaari naukri. LOL
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:4 IST)
Khalif: People say that Sudarshan Fakir is next to Ghalib. All these shayars are in same galazy. But Ghalib being the finest and brightest star of all.
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:4 IST)
kashif bhai. sarkari naukari ka matlab kaamchori nahiN hota hai
kashif (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:5 IST)
khudaa haafiz phir aayeNge gar kHuda laya. :-)
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:5 IST)
are re re, sudarshan fakir ko to mat rakho yaar yahaaN... he is far away
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:5 IST)
Gulzar has said of his own admission that he considers himself a 'banda of ghalib'.Ghalib without doubt is more superior ,however good gulzar maybe
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:5 IST)
Kashif:Zaroor.
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:5 IST)
khuda haafiz, kashif miyaaN
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:6 IST)
Sorry Vinay.
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:6 IST)
there's no doubt about that. Ghalib is far superior. I JUST SAID that Gulzar is same KIND of shaayar
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:7 IST)
I uset to think that I was fighting a lone battle,feeling so passionate about gulzar.Nice to know,I have fellow thinkers!
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:8 IST)
What about Ijaazat and Andhi?I loved those too and of course koshish
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:8 IST)
Let's stop the comparison between Ghalib and Gulzar. Ghalib is the great. But that doesn't prevent anybody from being good in their own class.
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:9 IST)
one of the very best both, though i liked Ijaazat more.
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:9 IST)
Out of the movies you've mentioned,uday-angoor is the only one i have'nt seen.How is it?
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:10 IST)
To tell you frankly whenever I feel lonely i bring Masoom , ijaazat Video cassetes and watch them. Otherwise listen to Angoor , Anand and Andhi and Mausam, Ghar etc.
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:10 IST)
angoor- that is Gulzar nonsense. He makes so much sense with his nonsensical works. tremendous stuff. no doubt he has done some of the best children works.
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:11 IST)
I have seen Ijaazat more than 15 times and every single time its a new experience to me I have stopped counting now. Angoor is a comedy movie based on Shekspere's 'Comedy of Error'. Its too good mess.
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:11 IST)
Gulzar without being the greatest poetis the most sensitive of our times.I think his daughter Bosky is an incredibly priveleged young woman to have him for a father.Did you know that Gulzar periodically ,every year published books for children because there weren't any god books for bosky to read?Incredible man
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:13 IST)
may be exaggerated a bit, but sadly it's true. there are hardly any good books for children. and gulzar has done some exceptional work - be it books, TV serials, movies
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:13 IST)
Has anyone read 'ravi paar' or his collection of poems 'Silences' and'Kuch aur nazmen'?His writing is very simple but amzingly articulate,not to mention intense!
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:14 IST)
I know that he wrote a poem for her on each of her Birthday. What a great gift from Father !. He loves 'Jungle jungle...' because kids love that song. And I am sure every single time I heard that song it brought back my childhood back to me in today's competative life.
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:15 IST)
Uday and Vinay ,is there some place like gulzar's website or something where I could talk to you more about him?I have to go now
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:15 IST)
i couldn't got ravi paar and silences. have phukhraj, mera kuchh samaan though.
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:15 IST)
I have read 'Raavi Paar' and 'Pukhraaj'
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:15 IST)
your email ID shruti? you may be a member of the Pancham egroup. we have all kinda discussions there. go to the Fanatics section of http://pancham.cjb.net
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:16 IST)
Shruti : You can go to pavan's site. that is www. rajcomp.com/pavan/gulzar.htm or my email address is udarajd@hotmail.com. There is a diccussion forum on Delphi. Once again thanks to pavan. Vinay : lets continue talking.
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:17 IST)
mine is vpj@bigfoot.com
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:18 IST)
Vinay : to bhai saab aap dialogues ke baare mai baat karana chhahate ho. Aap shuru kijiye mai hoon.
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:19 IST)
is shruti gone? uday: u there?
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:19 IST)
would love to stay,guys,but got to go!I'll try to get into the forum you mentioned.can you give me the time when I can meet you guys?Also,how does one get into Delphi?
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:19 IST)
Yes I am still there.
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:20 IST)
it is this time only that i m usually free..just mail. or ICQ my iCQ# is 7831633
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:20 IST)
Shruti:I am in US and Vinay is in Jaipur. Its not that easy to meet in person.
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:20 IST)
Uday,ans me please
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:21 IST)
no,no!Imeant,in which chat room,and if things permit I'd love to meet two Gulzar fans in person,too.
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:21 IST)
Shruti : Where are you ? As i said I am in US, I would love to be in contact with you through mails and we can talk about Gulzar Saab.
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:22 IST)
Hey Vinay : This time you start man. Lets talk about his genius as a writer.
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:23 IST)
welcome to Jaipur, Shruti!
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:23 IST)
well, i like almost all his written work, except for some where he plays with words just for the sake of it
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:24 IST)
I am in bangalore,Uday
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:24 IST)
Vinay: I have just posted my mail about Gulzar Saab's work to your id at vpj@bigfoot.com
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:24 IST)
shruti, u haven't given ur mail ID. also ICQ is a great way to keep in touch,
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:25 IST)
What is ICQ ? I don't know.
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:25 IST)
i am checking my mail uday
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:26 IST)
I'll send a mail to Uday and if you like,you can take my mail address from him.I'm not about to post me email-id for all and sundry to look at!paranoia?yes!
forrest (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:26 IST)
GULZAAR SAHAB, MY NAME IS RAHUL AND I HAVE WORKED WITH SHRI ARUN KAUL. AT PRESENT I AM A REPORTER WORKING IN A TOP TV NETWORK. I WANT TO ASSIST YOU IN FILM MAKING. KINDLY ADVISE
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:26 IST)
it's a piece of software. about3 MB in size. kinda buddy list. facilitates instant messaging, chat, file transfers and a whole lot of things between buddies. www.icq.com
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:27 IST)
Shruti : Do you have my email-id ? Its udayrajd@hotmail.com
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:27 IST)
uday,you haven't answered me about how to access delphi to talk to you
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:28 IST)
I need to install it. And also we need to take care of timings. We can be in constant touch.
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:28 IST)
Uday: where did u post this mail originally
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:29 IST)
DEAR FORREST, GULZAR SAAB ISN'T AROUND.SEND ANY QUERIES YOU HAVE TO HIS WEBSITE ,TAKE IT FROM UDAY
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:29 IST)
Shruti: you can go to Pavan's site and follow the link 'Thodisi zamin thoda aasman..' You have to register as a user. And you will know how to go next from there.
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:30 IST)
Uday,answer mw as soon as possible-how do I get into delphi or wherever,my login hours are spiralling!
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:30 IST)
I posted on Delphi.
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:31 IST)
Shruti : I have answered that question of getting into Delphi. Vinay : what do you think about the mail.
shruti (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:31 IST)
Thanks,Uday-will do.bye to you and Vinay
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:32 IST)
Thanks shruti.
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:32 IST)
bye shruti
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:33 IST)
go thru it later with time.
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:33 IST)
To abhi aap shuru karo.
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:35 IST)
Vinay:Are bhai aap kaha ho ?
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:36 IST)
it seems
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:36 IST)
uday, mmaf karna bhai, ek dost aa gaye haiN aur mujhe jaana paD.ega
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:37 IST)
Vinay : Aap kya bol rahe ho muzhe kuchh samaz nahi aa raha hai. Jara elaborate karo to achha ho.
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:37 IST)
Chalo to phir bye then keep in touch.
vinay (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:39 IST)
ok Uday, see you again. Keep mailing.. and do send your appl. for pancham egroup from the web site
Uday (Sat Jul 17 1999 6:39 IST)
Bye Vinay.
pavanj (Sat Jul 17 1999 7:10 IST)
Hello Friends Just to tell you that the transcript is almost ready You can check it in couple of hours
|
